Donate

Outline of Remarks on SB 187

by kathryn hickok
February 6, 2007
Tax and Budget

John A. Charles, Jr.

  • The primary effect of Oregon’s land-use regulatory system (especially the use of UGBs and rural downzoning) is to create various real estate cartels. By making buildable land scarce where it would otherwise be plentiful, land-use regulation drives up land prices far above market value.

  • The planning emphasis on higher-density, mixed-use developments adds additional costs; such projects are much more expensive.
  • The problems caused by real estate cartels cannot be solved by SB 187. Local governments are almost always dominated by homeowners whose land is over-valued. They have no incentive to add land supply that would have the effect of bursting the real estate bubble.
  • It’s counter-productive to focus on “affordable housing” as a special (subsidized) type of housing. We should seek to make all housing as affordable as possible by allowing markets to work in land supply, building design, infrastructure, and labor. Our current system makes all four of these inputs vastly more expensive then is necessary.
  • According to a Brookings Institution study of the 50 largest metropolitan regions, “The weight of the evidence suggests that places with stricter land use regulations differ systematically from those where they are less strict. The evidence is clearest (because it has been sought most zealously) about housing prices, which are higher in strictly regulated places.”
  • Brookings found that those cities with the least amount of zoning – Dallas, San Antonio and Houston – had the cheapest rents and the lowest home prices of all cities. Not only that, the three Texas regions had lower concentrations of poverty, higher home ownership rates, and larger concentrations of college graduates than cities with strict growth controls such as urban growth boundaries.
Share Post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Related News

SB 1537 cm
Land Use
Thursday, 15 February
2

Oregon Needs More Than Tiny Homes

By John A. Charles, Jr. The 35-day session of the...
Read more
Willamette Cove Is the Reset Button Metro Needs cm 1
Environment
Thursday, 21 January
0

Willamette Cove Is the Reset Button Metro Needs

By Helen Doran What does an old industrial site from...
Read more
Why Is Affordable Housing So Expensive cm 1
Land Use
Thursday, 25 February
2

Why Is “Affordable Housing” So Expensive?

By Vlad Yurlov Why is “affordable housing” so expensive? Many...
Read more
Letter to PPS Board Recommendations for Jefferson Highschool Modernization Project cm
Education
Wednesday, 03 April
0

Letter to PPS Board: Recommendations for Jefferson Highschool Modernization Project

April 2, 2024 Mr. Gary HollandsChair, Portland Public School Board501...
Read more
EVs bad business cm
Economic Opportunity
Wednesday, 05 June
0

EVs = bad business

By Emily Schutte Electric Vehicles are bad business. To boost...
Read more
new roof installation cm
Economic Opportunity
Wednesday, 22 April
0

Portland’s homeless population needs a “hand-up,” not another Metro money grab

By Rachel Dawson The Oregon nonprofit Cascadia Clusters understands the...
Read more
Portland Vista cm
Economic Opportunity
Friday, 30 August
1

Residents Say Portland is Not the City that Works

By Eric Fruits, Ph.D. What if the self-proclaimed “City that...
Read more
Dollar Flying in City cm
Economic Opportunity
Wednesday, 26 June
1

Portland’s Ill-Considered Climate Action Tax

By Micah Perry Last fall, Portland voters approved a new...
Read more
Steigende Preise für Immobilien 10.09.18 Large cm
Tax and Budget
Wednesday, 24 October
0

Metro’s Bond Measure 26-199 Raises Taxes on Homeowners, Requires No Accountability for Money Spent

By Miranda Bonifield Metro claims Measure 26-199 is designed to...
Read more
By 2027, All Alabama Students Will Have Educational Choice cm
Education
Wednesday, 27 March
0

By 2027, All Alabama Students Will Have Educational Choice

By Kathryn Hickok This month, Alabama became the most recent...
Read more
New construction of a house Framed New Construction of a House Building a new house from the ground up cm
Land Use
Wednesday, 20 May
0

Metro has a history of breaking promises to voters. The housing bond measure is no exception.

By Rachel Dawson Metro has a history of breaking promises...
Read more
Make Oregon the Opportunity State cm 1
Economic Opportunity
Wednesday, 10 February
1

Make Oregon the Opportunity State

By Eric Fruits, Ph.D. Oregonians blame Californians for many of...
Read more
Accessibility by WAH