Oregon state legislators are busy working to pass bills that they hope will generate $800 million income tax dollars from wealthy individuals and corporations.

The personal income tax bill would impose higher tax rates on households with taxable income above $250,000 along with single filers whose income tops $125,000. Supporters think they can raise about $500 million over two years, but that’s only if economic realities don’t get in the way.

As the Wall Street Journal recently pointed out, the state of Maryland tried something similar last year. It created a “millionaire tax bracket” and the Baltimore Sun predicted the rich would “grin and bear it.”  We’ll, they didn’t. The number of millionaire returns dropped by a third, in part because lots of incomes were down in the recession, but also because it’s the wealthy who find it easiest to move to less tax-burdensome states. 

Still, one Oregon tax advocate argues that the rich “can’t just not show up.”

But arguing that we should tax the rich more because they have to “show up” and therefore pay up won’t sit well with most fair-minded Oregonians. They know that most high income earners work hard for their money, just like the rest of us, and many of them are business owners who employ other Oregonians. And virtually all Oregonians, fair-minded or not, know that the rich are more able than most of us to avoid excess taxation by moving; just look at all those rich former Portlander’s now enjoying life on the other side of the Columbia River.

 

One Response to “Why taxing the rich may backfire”

  1. Anonymous July 29, 2009 at 11:21 am #

    The “rich” on the other side of the Columbia? They still have to pay taxes on income earned in Oregon until the State of Washington has an income tax.

    Maryland was just a case of tax payers deferring income into future years as the tax was temporary.

    Since the Federal Income Tax maximum for capital gains increases after 2010, there will be millions to be made as many individuals will cash out of the market (if they aready haven’t) to take advantage of 15% Federal Tax Maximum.

    Your just wrong as usual “Buck”.

Leave a Reply

Other Publications by Steve

Bill Meyer talks with Steve Buckstein about right to work in education

Steve Buckstein | May 18, 2012
KMED host Bill Meyer spoke with Cascade Senior Policy Analyst Steve Buckstein about the philosophy of right to work, education unions, and the Eagle Point ...  read more

Steve Buckstein talks with Victoria Taft about Oregon’s burning school system

Steve Buckstein | May 15, 2012
Cascade Senior Policy Analyst Steve Buckstein talked with KPAM host Victoria Taft about his last commentary, “Rescue children from our burning school system.”  read more

Rescue Children from Our Burning Public School System

Steve Buckstein | May 9, 2012
Newark, New Jersey Mayor Cory Booker is a larger-than-life figure fighting for what he calls the “Most Important Civil Right of All – equal access ...  read more

More On These Topics

Bill Post interviews Sarah Ross on a need for competition in education

KYKN radio host, Bill Post spoke with Cascade Communications Coordinator Sarah Ross on Thursday to discuss the evolution of technology and a need for competition ...  read more

Bill Meyer talks with Steve Buckstein about right to work in education

Steve Buckstein | May 18, 2012
KMED host Bill Meyer spoke with Cascade Senior Policy Analyst Steve Buckstein about the philosophy of right to work, education unions, and the Eagle Point ...  read more

Insolvency, One Step at a Time

John Charles | May 16, 2012
The Oregonian on Sunday examined TriMet’s deteriorating finances and called attention to high-cost union contracts, first approved in 1994, as the starting point of the ...  read more