State Treasurer Ted Wheeler has proposed that the state obligate its citizens to repay hundreds of millions of dollars in General Obligation bonds to subsidize student higher education costs. Below is the prepared testimony that I gave to a House committee last week and will give to a Senate committee tomorrow, setting out my objections to the plan:

I oppose HJR 6SB 11 and SJR 1 for several reasons.

First, as Professor Richard Vedder, author of the book “Going Broke By Degree: Why College Costs Too Much,” says, higher education prices are rising rapidly because of the predominant role of third-party payments, including federal and state support for institutions and students. “When some else is paying a lot of the bills, students are less sensitive to the price, thus allowing the colleges to care less about keeping prices under control.”

So, rather than help keep college costs and student debt levels down, Treasurer Wheeler’s proposal will likely do just the opposite.

That would be bad enough, but it will be worse because even if the investment assumptions for his proposal work out, taxpayers will be on the hook to repay hundreds of millions of dollars of bond principal, plus interest decades into the future.

Worse yet, there is evidence that more government funding of higher education actually translates to slower state economic growth. That’s likely because individuals know their needs better than politicians do, so leaving the money in private hands produces better economic results.

Further, academics such as Charles Murray and Carl Bankstron join Dr. Vedder in arguing that four-year degrees aren’t what they used to be, and that state funding may simply waste precious financial and human resources.

All that said, if increasing the percentage of Oregonians who earn two- and four-year degrees is a good goal, you should step back and look at efforts in other states to significantly reduce the cost of those degrees. Arthur Brooks recently noted in the New York Times that one idea gaining traction is the $10,000 college degree, which public universities in several states are moving toward right now. That’s $10,000 total direct costs for four years. According to Brooks, this “is exactly the kind of innovation we would expect in an industry that is showing every indication of a bubble that is about to burst.”

In conclusion, whatever the value of a college degree to an individual, it’s becoming clear that state funding of those degrees is likely to cost taxpayers more than they gain. I urge you to reject HJR 6, SB 11 and SJR 1.

Thank you.

 

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

 

Other Publications by Steve

As ObamaCare Turns Four, How’s It Working out for You?

Steve Buckstein | March 26, 2014
The Affordable Care Act turned four years old last Sunday. So how’s it working out for you? If you’re one of the millions who lost, ...  read more

As the Affordable Care Act Turns Four, Cascade’s Predictions Were on the Mark

| March 24, 2014
Sunday, March 23, was the fourth anniversary of the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (“ObamaCare”). Cascade founder and senior policy analyst ...  read more

Income Inequality: A Problem That Isn’t

Steve Buckstein | March 6, 2014
The debate over “income inequality” has simmered for some time, but now seems to be upfront as a key dividing line in American politics. President ...  read more

More On These Topics

New Education Study Shows: We’re Paying More for Less

Kathryn Hickok | March 19, 2014
Advocates on all sides of the public education spending-versus-results debate cite various statistics to make their respective cases. Some argue that more money leads to ...  read more

Too Little of a Good Thing

Cascade Policy Institute | February 19, 2014
By William Newell The recent Portland School Board decision to expand enrollment at Benson Polytechnic High School exemplifies an odd mindset within the public education ...  read more

Cascade in the Capitol: Testimony for the House Education Committee Against SB 1538 which would limit new charter school options

Steve Buckstein | February 18, 2014
February 19, 2014 Testimony Against SB 1538 Before the Oregon House Education Committee Chair Gelser and members of the Committee, my name is Steve Buckstein. ...  read more