Steve BucksteinQuickPoint!

Multnomah County voters just approved Oregon’s only local income tax, primarily to help schools. The 1.25 percent three-year tax is on top of Oregon’s already high 9 percent state income tax. Voters clearly value education, but this new money will largely benefit the teachers’ union, not the students. Rather than help the schools in a positive way, the new tax will allow the school system to avoid doing two things it must eventually do: control spending and become accountable for learning outcomes.

First, supporters of the new tax failed to recognize that school districts don’t have a budget shortfall so much as they have a spending problem. Giving districts more money will do nothing to correct their spending behavior. The Portland district, for example, had a real opportunity to curb out-of-control benefit costs during contract negotiations earlier this year. However, once the measure was proposed by Portland’s Mayor and Multnomah County’s Chairwoman, the school district board caved in and gave the teachers’ union virtually everything it wanted.

Second, with the passage of Measure 26-48, the teachers union got its wish: ever increasing funding without any connection to student learning. While audits may ensure that this new money goes into the classroom, nothing will stop existing school funds from flowing into administration or ever-growing employee benefits. The new tax is all about inputs. There is no accountability for learning outcomes.

So, voters did more than give the school system a new source of revenue. They rejected the opportunity to rein in costs and make the system accountable for student learning. Once again, the adults in the system came out winners, and the students came out losers.

Steve Buckstein is senior policy analyst at Cascade Policy Institute, a Portland, Oregon based think tank.

© 2006, Cascade Policy Institute. All rights reserved. Permission to reprint in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided the author and Cascade Policy Institute are cited. Contact Cascade at (503) 242-0900 to arrange print or broadcast interviews on this topic. For more topics visit the QuickPoint! archive.

 

Other Publications by Steve

Tear Down Oregon’s (Self-Created) Berlin Walls!

Steve Buckstein | November 14, 2014
The Berlin Wall came down twenty-five years ago this week. The Wall, which separated East and West Berlin, was one of the most powerful visible ...  read more

A Time for Choosing

Steve Buckstein | November 5, 2014
Did you choose between a left or right in yesterday’s election? If that phrase sounds familiar, perhaps you watched an emerging leader utter it 50 ...  read more

More Tax Dollars for College ― Or Prepare Students to Succeed There?

Steve Buckstein | October 16, 2014
Oregon voters are being asked this November to authorize spending more tax dollars to help some students afford an arguably unaffordable higher education. Measure 86 ...  read more

More On These Topics

Scare Tactics Not Working in Road Tax Debates

John Charles | November 19, 2014
The Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) recently issued a report describing the deteriorating condition of Oregon highways. The authors estimate that the cumulative cost to ...  read more

Tear Down Oregon’s (Self-Created) Berlin Walls!

Steve Buckstein | November 14, 2014
The Berlin Wall came down twenty-five years ago this week. The Wall, which separated East and West Berlin, was one of the most powerful visible ...  read more

Arizonans Gain the “Right to Try” to Save Their Lives

Cascade Policy Institute | November 12, 2014
Amid last week’s election excitement, Arizonans overwhelmingly approved their “Right to Try” referendum, allowing terminally ill patients access to experimental drugs that have completed basic ...  read more